Engineer reviewing remote management settings on a laptop in a server room

MSP security audit sample report

MSP Security Audit Sample Report

Every report from a full audit cycle for a fictional managed service provider, page by page: from the first audit to the third.

25+ yearsIT & cybersecurity experience
Certified expertsCISSP · C|CISO · Microsoft · Cisco
Southern CaliforniaLocal and on-site, based in Irvine
NationwideRemote audits & advisory

Our deliverables

Nine deliverables from a full MSP audit cycle

An MSP security audit has to serve three audiences at once: the owners who decide, the engineers who fix, and the clients and insurers who want proof. Each deliverable below is shown page by page in a slideshow, with a caption that explains what the page contains.

The sample follows one provider through three audits. The first audit found 119 findings and a posture score of 45.4 out of 100; after two rounds of remediation the third audit recorded 86 open findings and a score of 68.5. Most slides come from the first audit; the scorecard and the Remediation History show the later audits.

Sample data. These reports were produced for Harborline Technology Group, a fictional managed service provider with 64 clients, about 3,900 endpoints and 19 technical staff. All names, figures and observations are illustrative, and the three audits are shown on a sample timeline.

45.4First audit · Weak119 findings · 5 Critical and 12 High risks
63.3Second audit · Needs improvement100 findings · no Critical risks
68.5Third audit · Needs improvement86 findings · 33 issues resolved since audit 1
01

PDF and Word · 14 pages

Executive Security Report

The decision document for the owners of the provider. It states the posture score and rating, the business risks that matter most, what a compromise of the provider could reach across its clients, what is already working and the decisions only leadership can make. It is written in plain language, without tool names or jargon.

Who uses it

Owners, partners and leadership; also the basis for conversations with insurers and large clients.

What is included

  • Executive summary and posture score
  • Top business risks with owners and dates
  • Reach of a provider compromise
  • Score for each of the 18 areas
  • What is working well
  • Ten priority recommendations
  • Remediation phases
  • Decisions requested from leadership
  • Scope and approach

Sample · Harborline Technology Group (fictional)

1 / 10

Executive Security Report: Cover page (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 1 of 10Cover pageThe report is written for the owners and leadership of the managed service provider, here the fictional Harborline Technology Group.
Executive Security Report: Executive summary and posture score (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 2 of 10Executive summary and posture score151 controls in 18 areas give a posture score of 45.4 out of 100 (Weak), with 119 findings grouped into 21 business risks, 5 of them Critical.
Executive Security Report: Top business risks (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 3 of 10Top business risksThe five Critical risks, each with an owner and a target date, and the attack chain they form, starting with departed technicians who keep access to client systems.
Executive Security Report: What a compromise of the provider would reach (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 4 of 10What a compromise of the provider would reachHow many of the 64 clients and 3,900 endpoints each open finding could reach, based on the provider's stated scope.
Executive Security Report: Security posture by area (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 5 of 10Security posture by areaA score for each of the 18 areas against a benchmark of 85, with the number of controls that meet it and the findings in each area.
Executive Security Report: What is working well (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 6 of 10What is working wellCredit for controls that are already strong, such as EDR on 3,840 of 3,900 client endpoints and per-client backup encryption keys.
Executive Security Report: Priority recommendations (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 7 of 10Priority recommendationsTen actions for the highest-rated findings, each linked to a business risk and a timeframe that follows its severity.
Executive Security Report: Remediation phases (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 8 of 10Remediation phasesA timeline of the containment and remediation phases across the first 180 days.
Executive Security Report: Decisions requested from leadership (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 9 of 10Decisions requested from leadershipThe decisions only owners can make, such as funding credential rotation, mandating phishing-resistant MFA and approving immutable backups.
Executive Security Report: Scope and approach (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 10 of 10Scope and approachThe organization profile, the platforms in scope and the assessment method, with the assessor's details.

Click the centre page to open it full size and zoom in.

02

PDF and Word · 156 pages

Technical Security Report

The full record of the audit for the people who will fix it. Every control result is listed, and every finding has its own page with the observation, the evidence reviewed, the business impact, the recommendation and how to confirm the fix, grouped by the 18 areas and mapped to frameworks.

Who uses it

Head of technology, engineers, security staff and the auditors of a later certification.

What is included

  • Result and severity definitions
  • Environment and platforms in scope
  • Summary of results and charts
  • Scores by area and findings index
  • Key observations for each area
  • A detail page for every finding
  • Controls that meet the benchmark
  • Framework reference appendix

Sample · Harborline Technology Group (fictional)

1 / 13

Technical Security Report: Contents (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 1 of 13ContentsThe report runs from the introduction and environment overview to detailed findings in 18 areas and a framework appendix.
Technical Security Report: Result and severity definitions (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 2 of 13Result and severity definitionsHow each control result (Pass, Partial, Fail, Not assessed, Not applicable) and each severity level is defined, so the scoring can be checked.
Technical Security Report: Environment overview (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 3 of 13Environment overviewThe provider's scope: 64 client organizations, about 3,900 endpoints, a technical team of 19 and the platforms through which it reaches clients.
Technical Security Report: Summary of results (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 4 of 13Summary of results151 of 151 applicable controls assessed: 32 meet the benchmark, 78 are partial and 41 are missing, for a score of 45.4 out of 100.
Technical Security Report: Findings by area (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 5 of 13Findings by areaA stacked chart of the findings in each area by severity, showing where the weaknesses concentrate.
Technical Security Report: Scores by area and findings index (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 6 of 13Scores by area and findings indexThe score of every area against the benchmark of 85, followed by an index of every finding with its control, severity, result and linked risk.
Technical Security Report: Key observations by area (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 7 of 13Key observations by areaEach area opens with what it covers, its score and its findings in plain words, starting with governance, risk and compliance.
Technical Security Report: Finding detail: client credential rotation (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 8 of 13Finding detail: client credential rotationA Critical finding in client credential and secrets management: no rotation triggers or schedule for client passwords, with the evidence and the fix.
Technical Security Report: Finding detail: RMM script governance (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 9 of 13Finding detail: RMM script governanceA High finding on the remote-management platform: scripts and automation run without review, approval or a second check before mass deployment.
Technical Security Report: Finding detail: delegated admin access (GDAP) (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 10 of 13Finding detail: delegated admin access (GDAP)A Critical finding on privileged access to client environments: Microsoft CSP access must use granular, time-bound delegated admin privileges, not legacy relationships.
Technical Security Report: Finding detail: help-desk identity verification (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 11 of 13Finding detail: help-desk identity verificationThe Critical finding with the widest reach: password and MFA resets without a callback or verification step, which invites social engineering.
Technical Security Report: Controls meeting the benchmark (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 12 of 13Controls meeting the benchmarkEvery control that already meets the benchmark, with its area and maturity, so the report shows strengths as well as gaps.
Technical Security Report: Framework reference appendix (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 13 of 13Framework reference appendixEach finding mapped to NIST CSF 2.0 and other framework references, for use in client questionnaires and audits.

Click the centre page to open it full size and zoom in.

03

PDF and Word · 26 pages, landscape

Risk Register

The register that turns findings into business risks a leadership team can own. Each risk has a likelihood, an impact, a score, a rating, an owner, a target date and a treatment plan, and every finding is traced to the risk it feeds.

Who uses it

Leadership and risk owners; also useful for insurers, auditors and enterprise clients.

What is included

  • Risk scoring method
  • Risk profile and heat maps
  • Risk summary with owners and dates
  • Current versus residual risk
  • A detail page for each risk
  • Finding-to-risk traceability

Sample · Harborline Technology Group (fictional)

1 / 7

Risk Register: Risk scoring method (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 1 of 7Risk scoring methodEach risk is scored as likelihood (1 to 5) times impact (1 to 5), with each level defined in business terms.
Risk Register: Risk profile (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 2 of 7Risk profile21 business risks: 5 Critical, 12 High and 4 Medium, shown as inherent risk today and residual risk after treatment.
Risk Register: Risk summary (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 3 of 7Risk summaryEvery risk with its likelihood, impact, score, rating, owner, target date and status.
Risk Register: Current versus residual risk (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 4 of 7Current versus residual riskA chart comparing the current and residual scores of the highest-rated risks once treatment is complete.
Risk Register: Risk detail: departed technicians keep access (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 5 of 7Risk detail: departed technicians keep accessR-01 in full: risk statement, linked findings and controls, treatment plan, owner and target score.
Risk Register: Risk detail: standing privilege in client tenants (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 6 of 7Risk detail: standing privilege in client tenantsR-02: legacy delegated admin privileges and permanent global administrator roles that give any compromised account full control of client tenants.
Risk Register: Finding-to-risk traceability (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 7 of 7Finding-to-risk traceabilityEvery finding mapped to the business risk it feeds, so each fix can be traced to the risk it reduces.

Click the centre page to open it full size and zoom in.

04

PDF and Word · 22 pages

Next Steps and Security Roadmap

The plan that turns the audit into work. It starts with containment in the first seven days, then sets out what to complete within 30, 90 and 180 days, grouped into projects with priority, effort and duration, and the governance rhythm to keep it on track.

Who uses it

Operations, project leads and the head of technology who will run the remediation.

What is included

  • Today, 30 days and 180 days compared
  • Phase 0 containment, days 0 to 7
  • Critical, High and Medium phases
  • Numbered security projects
  • Expected outcome and residual risk
  • Future goals for 6 to 18 months
  • Governance and operating rhythm

Sample · Harborline Technology Group (fictional)

1 / 7

Next Steps and Security Roadmap: Where you are and where you should be (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 1 of 7Where you are and where you should beKey indicators today, after the Critical actions at 30 days and after the full roadmap at 180 days, starting with the posture score of 45.4.
Next Steps and Security Roadmap: Remediation roadmap (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 2 of 7Remediation roadmapPhase 0 immediate containment in days 0 to 7, starting with checking that every technician who left in the last 12 months has no remaining access.
Next Steps and Security Roadmap: Recommended security projects (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 3 of 7Recommended security projectsRelated actions grouped into numbered projects with priority, linked findings, duration and effort.
Next Steps and Security Roadmap: Project detail (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 4 of 7Project detailEach project has an objective, its steps and its scope, such as one minimum security standard for every client tenant, endpoint and network.
Next Steps and Security Roadmap: Expected outcome (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 5 of 7Expected outcomeThe expected reduction of the highest-rated risks and the residual heat map once the roadmap is complete.
Next Steps and Security Roadmap: Future goals (6 to 18 months) (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 6 of 7Future goals (6 to 18 months)Longer-term goals such as independent assurance (SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001 or MSP Verify) and zero-trust access to client environments.
Next Steps and Security Roadmap: Governance and operating rhythm (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 7 of 7Governance and operating rhythmWho reviews progress, how often and what each review produces, starting with a weekly remediation review.

Click the centre page to open it full size and zoom in.

05

PDF and Word · 2 pages per audit

MSP Security Scorecard

A two-page summary that a provider can share. It shows the overall rating, the key numbers, the score of each area, the top business risks and the strongest areas, in a form owners, sales teams and clients can read in minutes. A new scorecard is issued after every audit.

Who uses it

Owners, account managers, client reviews and insurance renewals.

What is included

  • Overall rating and score
  • Controls, findings and business risks
  • Score by area
  • Top business risks
  • Strongest areas
  • What the result means

Sample · Harborline Technology Group (fictional)

1 / 3

MSP Security Scorecard: Scorecard, first audit (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 1 of 3Scorecard, first auditA two-page summary for owners and clients: overall rating Weak (45.4 out of 100), 151 controls, 119 findings and the top business risks.
MSP Security Scorecard: Strongest areas and what this means (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 2 of 3Strongest areas and what this meansThe strongest areas with their scores and a plain-language statement of what the result means for the provider and its clients.
MSP Security Scorecard: Scorecard, third audit (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 3 of 3Scorecard, third auditThe same scorecard after two re-audits: rating Needs improvement (68.5 out of 100), 65 controls meeting the benchmark and 86 findings.

Click the centre page to open it full size and zoom in.

06

PDF and Word · 26 pages

Client Exposure Analysis

The report that is specific to auditing a provider. It answers one question for leadership: if a weakness found in the audit were used by an attacker, how far could it reach? Each open finding is expressed in clients, endpoints and staff, with the basis of every number stated.

Who uses it

Leadership, insurers and large clients who want to understand concentration risk.

What is included

  • Purpose and method
  • Summary of the widest-reaching findings
  • Four MSP compromise scenarios
  • Reach of every open finding
  • Methodology and basis of every number

Sample · Harborline Technology Group (fictional)

1 / 5

Client Exposure Analysis: Purpose and method (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 1 of 5Purpose and methodOne question for leadership: if a weakness were used by an attacker, how many clients, endpoints and staff could it reach?
Client Exposure Analysis: Summary (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 2 of 5SummaryBased on 64 clients and 3,900 endpoints, 12 findings could reach the entire client base, led by help-desk identity verification.
Client Exposure Analysis: Compromise scenarios (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 3 of 5Compromise scenariosThe four ways an MSP is most often compromised: the RMM platform, the credential vault, delegated admin access and backup destruction.
Client Exposure Analysis: Reach of every open finding (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 4 of 5Reach of every open findingEvery open finding with its estimated reach in clients, endpoints and staff, widest first, and a plain-words pathway.
Client Exposure Analysis: Methodology and basis of every number (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 5 of 5Methodology and basis of every numberHow each figure is calculated: stated scope, measured counts and estimates, so leadership can see what each number rests on.

Click the centre page to open it full size and zoom in.

07

PDF and Word · 32 pages

Certification Readiness

A readiness indicator for the assurance programs clients ask providers about, calculated from the same control results. It shows readiness by program, by theme and by item, lists the priority gaps and recommends what to close before engaging an auditor. It is not a certification opinion.

Who uses it

Leadership and the compliance lead planning SOC 2, ISO/IEC 27001 or MSP Verify.

What is included

  • SOC 2 Trust Services Criteria
  • ISO/IEC 27001:2022 Annex A
  • MSPAlliance MSP Verify
  • CIS Controls v8.1 IG1
  • HIPAA Security Rule
  • NIST CSF 2.0
  • Priority gaps and next steps

Sample · Harborline Technology Group (fictional)

1 / 7

Certification Readiness: SOC 2 Trust Services Criteria (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 1 of 7SOC 2 Trust Services CriteriaReadiness against the SOC 2 Common Criteria plus Availability and Confidentiality, with the open findings behind each gap.
Certification Readiness: ISO/IEC 27001:2022 Annex A (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 2 of 7ISO/IEC 27001:2022 Annex AReadiness by theme and for every Annex A control, including the controls the Statement of Applicability must cover from other evidence.
Certification Readiness: MSPAlliance MSP Verify (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 3 of 7MSPAlliance MSP VerifyReadiness against the MSP Verify objective groups, mapped from the assessment areas.
Certification Readiness: CIS Controls v8.1 IG1 (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 4 of 7CIS Controls v8.1 IG1The 56 Implementation Group 1 safeguards, the baseline most cyber insurance questionnaires are written against.
Certification Readiness: HIPAA Security Rule (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 5 of 7HIPAA Security RuleFor providers that serve healthcare clients as business associates: readiness against the administrative, physical and technical safeguards.
Certification Readiness: NIST Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 6 of 7NIST Cybersecurity Framework 2.0Readiness by Function and by Category, derived from the NIST CSF references of every control.
Certification Readiness: Next steps (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 7 of 7Next stepsWhat to do before engaging an auditor, starting with the priority gaps, so the provider does not pay for an examination it is not ready for.

Click the centre page to open it full size and zoom in.

08

PDF and Word · 39 pages, from the third audit

Remediation History (re-audits)

Issued from the second audit on. It compares every control with every earlier audit and shows what was fixed and verified, what is still open and for how long, and what is new or has regressed, so leadership, clients and insurers can see progress over the audit cycle.

Who uses it

Leadership, clients and insurers who want proof of progress between audits.

What is included

  • Audit timeline and score trend
  • Remediation summary
  • Issue-by-issue history
  • Issues verified as fixed
  • Issues still open
  • Recommendations
  • Audit History sheet in the workbook

Sample · Harborline Technology Group (fictional)

1 / 7

Remediation History (re-audits): Audit timeline (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 1 of 7Audit timelineThe posture score and open findings at each audit, from 45.4 and 119 findings at the first audit to 68.5 and 86 at the third.
Remediation History (re-audits): Remediation summary (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 2 of 7Remediation summarySince the first audit: 33 issues resolved, 1 improved, 84 unchanged or open, 1 worse or regressed and none new; 14 were verified as fixed in the third audit.
Remediation History (re-audits): Issue-by-issue history (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 3 of 7Issue-by-issue historyEvery control that was a finding in any audit, with its result in each audit, its status and when it was resolved.
Remediation History (re-audits): Issues verified as fixed (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 4 of 7Issues verified as fixedEach control fixed in this audit, with the original finding, what changed and the evidence that confirms the fix.
Remediation History (re-audits): Issues still open (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 5 of 7Issues still openThe 86 open issues, those open across several audits listed first, with the latest observation for each.
Remediation History (re-audits): Recommendations (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 6 of 7RecommendationsClose the long-standing items first, add the resolved controls to a quarterly self-check and keep the audit cadence.
Remediation History (re-audits): Audit History sheet (workbook) (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 7 of 7Audit History sheet (workbook)In the re-audit workbook, the result of every control in every audit, with its status, when it was resolved and how long it has been open.

Click the centre page to open it full size and zoom in.

09

Excel · 8 working sheets, plus Audit History in re-audits

Technical Findings Workbook

The working file for the remediation. It holds every finding, risk, roadmap action, area score, strength and evidence item in sortable sheets, with yellow input columns for status, owner and due date and summary counts that update as the provider closes items.

Who uses it

Engineers and project managers tracking the fixes week by week.

What is included

  • Summary that updates automatically
  • Findings ordered by severity
  • Risk register with live scoring
  • Remediation plan with status
  • Domain scores
  • Strengths
  • Evidence register

Sample · Harborline Technology Group (fictional)

1 / 7

Technical Findings Workbook: Summary sheet (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 1 of 7Summary sheetPosture score, controls assessed and open versus closed findings and risks, which update as the provider works through the fixes.
Technical Findings Workbook: Findings sheet (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 2 of 7Findings sheetEvery finding ordered by severity with its control, area, result, observation and business impact; more columns hold the fix, owner and status.
Technical Findings Workbook: Risk Register sheet (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 3 of 7Risk Register sheetThe 21 business risks with their statements, linked findings and controls, and likelihood, impact and score that recalculate when changed.
Technical Findings Workbook: Remediation Plan sheet (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 4 of 7Remediation Plan sheetEvery roadmap action by phase and window, with the area, finding, risk and a status column the provider updates.
Technical Findings Workbook: Domain Scores sheet (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 5 of 7Domain Scores sheetThe score and rating of each of the 18 areas, with control counts and results.
Technical Findings Workbook: Strengths sheet (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 6 of 7Strengths sheetThe controls that meet the benchmark, with title, area, severity and maturity.
Technical Findings Workbook: Evidence Register sheet (fictional company, illustrative data)
Slide 7 of 7Evidence Register sheetEvery evidence item collected during the assessment, such as policies, procedures and interview notes, with its type.

Click the centre page to open it full size and zoom in.

Your own audit

Get these reports for your provider

The MSP Security Audit is CISO-led and read-only, starts at $3,500 for one provider and includes every deliverable above.

Ali Hassani, CISO and CISSP, founder of OC Security Audit

Who leads the audit

Led by Ali Hassani, CISO

Certified CISO (C|CISO) and CISSP with 25+ years in IT, cybersecurity, compliance and infrastructure, and dozens of Microsoft and Cisco certifications, including MCSE, MCITP, MCSA Security, CCNP and CCNA.

Every MSP security audit is planned, performed and signed by Ali, not handed to a junior analyst. We stay independent: we assess and advise, and your team carries out the fixes, with our help if you want it.

Questions and answers

MSP sample report questions

Is this a real provider’s audit report?

No. Harborline Technology Group is a fictional managed service provider, and every name, figure and observation in the sample is invented. We never publish client data. The structure, depth and format are the same as the reports our clients receive.

Why are there three audits in the sample?

To show a full audit cycle. The first audit sets the baseline, and each re-audit compares every control with the earlier results. The scorecards and the Remediation History show how the score moved from 45.4 to 63.3 and then 68.5 as findings were fixed.

Which deliverables come with every MSP security audit?

The Executive Security Report, Technical Security Report, Risk Register, Next Steps and Security Roadmap, MSP Security Scorecard, Client Exposure Analysis, Certification Readiness report and the Technical Findings Workbook in Excel. The Remediation History is added from the second audit on.

Do we receive Word files or only PDFs?

Both. Reports come as Word and PDF files, and the findings workbook is an Excel file with input columns your team can update as items are closed.

Does the Certification Readiness report mean we are certified?

No. It is a readiness indicator calculated from the audit results. Certification and attestation decisions are made by the programs’ own auditors, such as a CPA firm for SOC 2 or an accredited body for ISO/IEC 27001.

How much does the audit that produces these reports cost?

The MSP Security Audit starts at $3,500 for one provider and includes every deliverable shown on this page for that audit.

ocsa pa h engineer laptop server room

See what your own reports would say

Book a short call to confirm your scope and price in writing before any work starts.

Or call 949-777-5567