Business owner looking concerned while reviewing email on a laptop
Business email compromise
2026-11-08 14:22:07Z New-InboxRule Name="." SubjectContains="invoice"

Business Email Compromise Investigation for Microsoft 365

A read-only review of the mailbox rules, forwarding, sign-ins and mail flow behind a fake invoice or redirected payment, with a timeline your bank, insurer and counsel can work from.

Senior executive working on a laptop in a bright office
Money moved?
Bank first · then ic3.gov · then preserve the mailbox

Call your bank first, then keep the records

If a payment went out, ask your bank to attempt a recall and report it to the FBI. Then keep the mailbox, rules and messages intact until they are exported.

Security engineer reviewing records at a desk in a data center
Hidden rules
Rule "." → moves to RSS Feeds → marks read → forwards outside

Find the rules built to stay hidden

Attackers name rules with a single character, file replies in RSS Feeds and forward copies outside. We export every rule and forwarding path before anyone deletes them.

From $3,500Defined mailboxes and period
Read-onlyRules exported, not deleted
TimelineFor bank, insurer and counsel
Fictional sampleSee every report page
How BEC looks in Microsoft 365

A redirected payment is rarely the whole story

By the time a vendor asks where their payment went, the attacker has usually been reading the mailbox for days or weeks, waiting for the right invoice.

A typical sequence: a phishing page captures a password or session, the attacker signs in, adds an inbox rule that hides replies about invoices, sets up forwarding to an outside address, and then sends a perfectly timed message with new bank details. Because the real conversation is hidden, nobody notices until money is missing.

  • Vendors or customers ask about invoices you never sent
  • Replies about payments go missing or appear as already read
  • Mail forwarded to an outside address, or a rule nobody created
  • Sign-ins to the mailbox from unfamiliar places or apps
CASE PATTERNFinance and leadership team meeting to review a payment incident
First steps

If a payment has already gone out

NOW

Call your bank and report it

Ask your bank to attempt a recall of the transfer and report the fraud to the FBI at ic3.gov. Speed matters for any recall attempt; we cannot recover funds.

NEXT

Contain without destroying records

Reset the password and revoke sessions as your IT provider advises, and write down every change. Do not delete the mailbox, the messages or the rules until they are exported.

Avoid before records are exported
  • Deleting suspicious inbox rules, forwarding or mail flow rules
  • Deleting the fraudulent emails or the conversation with the vendor
  • Removing or converting the mailbox, or removing the license
  • Discussing the incident by email from the affected mailbox
Why it matters

BEC remains one of the costliest reported crimes

$3.04B+

Business email compromise losses reported to the FBI in 2025.

FBI IC3 2025 Internet Crime Report
$20.9B

Total cybercrime losses reported to the FBI’s IC3 in 2025.

FBI IC3 2025 Internet Crime Report
180 days

Default Microsoft 365 Audit (Standard) retention for most audit records.

Microsoft Learn: Purview audit retention

Figures as published by the FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center and Microsoft Learn.

What we review

Every path mail can take out of your tenant

The review covers the affected mailboxes and the tenant-wide settings an attacker can use to hide or copy mail.

EXH-01

Inbox rules

Rules that forward, delete, mark as read or move mail to RSS Feeds, Archive or other quiet folders, including rules with blank or one-character names.

EXH-02

Forwarding

Mailbox-level forwarding, SMTP forwarding and the outbound policy that decides whether automatic external forwarding is allowed.

EXH-03

Mail flow rules

Tenant-wide transport rules that blind-copy, redirect or allow-list mail, and when they were created or changed.

EXH-04

Delegates and permissions

Full Access, Send As and Send on Behalf permissions, shared mailbox access and recently added delegates.

EXH-05

Sign-ins and sessions

Sign-ins to the mailbox by address, country, client and protocol, including legacy protocols such as IMAP and POP where enabled.

EXH-06

Applications and searches

Apps granted mail permissions, content searches for words such as invoice or wire, and mail access events where licensing records them.

Questions answered

The questions finance and leadership ask, and where answers come from

QuestionWhere the answer comes fromLimits
How did they get in?Sign-in logs, risk detections, MFA method changes, app consentsEntra sign-in logs: 7 days (Free) or 30 days (P1/P2)
When did it start?First suspicious sign-in, rule creation time, forwarding changesEarlier activity may have expired
What did they set up?Inbox rules, forwarding, mail flow rules, delegates, applicationsCurrent state plus audit history
Which messages left?Forwarding configuration, sent items, outbound messages to outside addressesDepends on what was kept and logged
What did they read?Mail access audit events where licensing and settings recorded themNot available in every tenant
Are they still in?Active sessions, remaining rules, consents and permissionsChecked at the time of review
Our process

From fake invoice to a closed mailbox

STEP 01 · SCOPE

Mailboxes, period and readers

We agree in writing which mailboxes and dates are in scope, the read-only access and who receives the report.

STEP 02 · EXPORT

Rules, forwarding and logs

Current rules and permissions are exported first, then sign-in and audit records for the period.

STEP 03 · TIMELINE

One timeline across sign-ins and mail

From the first suspicious sign-in to the fraudulent message, with every rule and change in date order.

STEP 04 · CLOSE

What is still open

Remaining rules, forwarding, sessions, apps and weak settings, listed for removal in priority order.

STEP 05 · REPORT

Executive and technical reports

Plain-language findings for leadership and counsel, technical detail for IT, and a 7-day containment plan.

Security team examining an alert on a monitor during an investigation
Two different problems

Compromised mailbox or look-alike domain?

Both end in a fake invoice, but they need different fixes. The first part of every BEC review settles which one you are dealing with.

Your mailbox was compromised

  • The fraudulent message is in your own Sent Items or was sent through your tenant
  • Suspicious sign-ins, new inbox rules or forwarding on the account
  • Fix: close the access, remove the rules, strengthen sign-in controls, review what else the account reached

Someone imitated your domain

  • The message came from a similar domain or a spoofed address outside your tenant
  • No matching sign-ins or rules in your environment
  • Fix: email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC enforcement), payment-verification procedures, and warning the vendors involved

It can also be the vendor’s mailbox that was compromised, not yours. In that case the review shows that your tenant was not the source, which is useful information for your bank, insurer and counsel.

After the investigation

Controls that make the next attempt harder

The roadmap in the report is specific to your tenant. These are the controls that most often appear in it after a BEC case.

CTL-01

Block automatic external forwarding

Outbound spam policy set so mailboxes cannot silently forward to outside addresses, with documented exceptions.

CTL-02

Phishing-resistant MFA

MFA enforced for every user through Conditional Access, stronger methods for finance and administrators, legacy protocols blocked.

CTL-03

DMARC enforcement

SPF and DKIM aligned and DMARC moved from monitoring to quarantine or reject, so outsiders cannot send as your domain.

CTL-04

Alerts on rule creation

Alert policies for new forwarding, suspicious inbox rules and mail flow rule changes, routed to someone who reads them.

CTL-05

Payment verification

A call-back procedure on a known phone number before any change to bank details, owned by finance, not IT.

CTL-06

Independent audit

A full Microsoft 365 security audit once the incident is closed, to find the weaknesses the attacker did not use yet.

Microsoft 365 security audit →
See before you book

See every page of a sample report

Five deliverables from a sample compromise assessment of a fictional company: executive report, technical report, risk register, 180-day roadmap and Excel workbook.

Sample executive summary page from a Microsoft 365 compromise assessment (fictional company, illustrative data)
Ali Hassani, CISO, OC Security Audit
CISO-led

Led by Ali Hassani, CISO

Certified CISO (C|CISO) and CISSP with 25+ years in IT and cybersecurity and dozens of Microsoft certifications. BEC reviews are read-only and written so finance, leadership and IT can act on the same facts.

We work with businesses in Irvine, across Orange County and Los Angeles County, and remotely nationwide.

FAQ

Business email compromise investigation questions

What is business email compromise in Microsoft 365?

Business email compromise (BEC) is when someone uses a compromised or look-alike mailbox to trick people into paying, changing bank details or sharing data. In Microsoft 365 it often involves a hidden inbox rule, external forwarding or a mail flow rule that lets the attacker watch and intercept invoice and payment conversations.

We sent a payment to a fraudulent account. What first?

Call your bank immediately and ask them to attempt a recall, then report it to the FBI at ic3.gov. Keep the emails involved; do not delete them. After that, have the mailbox records reviewed so you know how the fraud happened and whether access is still open.

Can you tell whether the attacker read our emails?

Sometimes. Mail access events such as MailItemsAccessed are recorded only with certain licenses and settings, and only for the retention period. Where those records exist, the review can show which items were accessed; where they do not, the report states that the question cannot be answered from the available records.

Was it our mailbox or a look-alike domain?

That is one of the first questions the review answers. Message headers, sent items, sign-ins and rules show whether mail came from your tenant or from an outside domain that imitates yours. The answer changes what you need to fix.

Will you remove the malicious rules?

The review is read-only. We export and document the rules, forwarding and permissions, then list them for removal by your administrator or IT provider. IT Perfection can make the changes under a separate agreement if you prefer.

Does this replace notifying customers or regulators?

No. Whether and how to notify is a legal decision for you and your counsel. The report gives counsel technical facts such as which mailboxes and time periods were affected.

How much does a BEC investigation cost?

BEC investigations start at $3,500 for a defined set of mailboxes and review period, confirmed in writing before work begins.

Important notes
  • OC Security Audit provides technical cybersecurity assessment, advisory and reporting services. We are not a law firm and do not provide legal advice, and we are not a private investigation agency.
  • An investigation reviews the records and settings available at the time of the review. Log retention, licensing and configuration limit what can be reconstructed, so no investigation can guarantee that every unauthorized action has been identified.
  • We do not identify or attribute attackers, recover data or funds, or make breach-notification, regulatory or insurance determinations. Those decisions belong to you, your legal counsel and your insurer.
  • Our reports are technical observations, not legal conclusions, and we make no representation that they are suitable as evidence in any legal proceeding.
  • We do not promise a response time. Scope, timing, price and deliverables are confirmed in a written agreement before any work begins. Investigations start at $3,500.
Implementation partner

From findings to fixes

OC Security Audit stays independent and read-only. If you want hands-on containment or remediation, IT Perfection can implement the changes under a separate agreement.

Visit IT Perfection
IT engineers reviewing systems together

Fake invoice, redirected payment or strange mailbox rules?

Call your bank first if money moved. Then call 949-777-5567 or schedule a consultation, and we will discuss scope and timing with you.

Compromise investigations start at $3,500 · Headquarters in Irvine, California · Remote nationwide