What the file share audit covers
Shared folders grow for years: departments, projects, scanned documents, payroll exports. Permissions pile up the same way, until “Everyone” can change the finance folder.
The audit reads every shared folder on the servers it inventories, its share permissions and its NTFS folder permissions at the share root and one level below by default. A share is only flagged as “everyone can change” when both the share permission and the folder permission allow it.
Part of the Windows Server & Active Directory Security Audit, one of 13 areas and 140 controls. Fixed price: $3,500.

9 File Shares & Permissions controls we evaluate
Each control ends as Pass, Fail, Warning, Manual review or Informational, with the evidence behind it. Some checks raise or lower the default severity to match what was found.
| ID | Control | Default severity |
|---|---|---|
| FS-01 | Shared folders that everyone can change | High |
| FS-02 | Sensitive shares readable by all staff | High |
| FS-03 | Permissions granted to individual users | Low |
| FS-04 | Folder permissions held by deleted accounts | Low |
| FS-05 | Access-based enumeration on departmental shares | Low |
| FS-06 | File shares hosted on domain controllers | Medium |
| FS-07 | Previous versions (shadow copies) on file servers | Low |
| FS-08 | Exposure of the backup repository | High |
| FS-09 | Folders with their own permission sets | Low |
What we look for and why
Write access for everyone
Shares where Everyone, Authenticated Users or Domain Users can change files give ransomware and careless deletes the widest reach. Rated High.
Sensitive data open to all staff
Shares whose names or locations suggest HR, finance, payroll or client data and are readable by all staff are listed for owner review.
Clean-up that pays off
Permissions granted to individual users or held by deleted accounts, missing access-based enumeration and file shares on domain controllers make permissions impossible to review. Each is counted.
A finding from the sample report
- Area
- File shares
- Finding
- Finance share can be changed by Domain Users
- Severity
- High
- Evidence
- Share “Finance$” on FILE01 grants Change to Everyone at the share level and Modify to Domain Users on the folder. The folder holds 2 years of payroll exports.
- Fix
- Replace Everyone and Domain Users with a Finance group, grant Modify only to that group, enable access-based enumeration, and move the payroll exports to a restricted location.
Every finding in the real report has this shape. See the full sample report
A read-only audit in five steps
Scoping call
We confirm the domain, the number of servers, Hyper-V hosts, file servers and who on your side should be told before the run.
Read-only collection
One script runs inside your network with a domain account. It reads Active Directory, DNS, DHCP and your Windows servers and writes one file. Nothing is installed or changed.
Offline analysis
The collection is analyzed on our side, offline: 140 controls in 13 areas, each Pass, Fail, Warning or Manual review with evidence.
Risk-rated findings
Findings are rolled up into business risks, mapped to NIST CSF 2.0, ISO/IEC 27001:2022 and CIS Controls v8.
Report and roadmap
Five reports and an Excel workbook, walked through on a call with your owner and your IT lead.
Page 11 of 18: File shares & permissions
- 1. Active Directory Security Audit (hub)
- 2. Active Directory health & design
- 3. Privileged access review
- 4. Accounts & password policy
- 5. Kerberos, delegation & certificates
- 6. Group Policy & delegation
- 7. Windows DNS security
- 8. Windows DHCP security
- 9. Domain controller hardening
- 10. Windows Server patching & hardening
- 11. File shares & permissions (this page)
- 12. Hyper-V & virtualization
- 13. Backup & recovery
- 14. Remote access & Entra Connect
- 15. Sample report
- 16. Active Directory security checklist
- 17. Pricing
- 18. How to audit Active Directory

Guided by Ali Hassani, CISO
Certified CISO (C|CISO) and CISSP with 25+ years in IT, cybersecurity, compliance and infrastructure, and dozens of Microsoft and Cisco certifications, including MCSE, MCITP, MCSA Security, CCNP and CCNA. Every Active Directory audit is read-only, evidence-based and written so an owner and an administrator can both act on it.
Questions IT leaders ask
Will reading permissions slow our file servers?
At the default depth (share root and first-level folders) the load is light. Deeper reads are optional and only run if you ask for them.
Does the audit change anything on our servers?
No. The collector contains only read commands. It never creates, changes or deletes anything in Active Directory, DNS, DHCP or on any server, and it installs nothing. The only thing it writes is its own output folder and one zip file on the computer where it runs.
Will anyone notice the audit?
End users see nothing: no e-mail, pop-up, restart or policy change. Your servers record normal logon events for the audit account, and a security tool such as Microsoft Defender for Identity may flag the directory read as enumeration. We tell your IT or security contact the date, time, account and computer in advance.
Do you read passwords?
No. Password fields, password hashes, LAPS passwords, shared secrets and private keys are never read. For LAPS we only check whether an expiry date exists.
Implementation partner
OC Security Audit stays independent and read-only. If you want hands-on administration, IT Perfection can implement the fixes: domain controller hardening, tiered admin accounts, LAPS, Group Policy cleanup, server patching and ongoing support.

Know how your domain would hold up, before an attacker tests it
Schedule a consultation. We scope the Active Directory and Windows Server audit in 30 minutes and quote one fixed price: $3,500, any organization size.
Read-only audit. No changes to your systems. Irvine, Orange County and Southern California on-site; remote nationwide.


