Security engineer reviewing Conditional Access sign-in results in a monitoring room
Microsoft Entra ID · Conditional Access

Conditional Access Policy Review: Do Your Policies Really Stop Risky Sign-ins?

A read-only review of every Conditional Access policy in your Microsoft Entra ID tenant: who is covered, who is excluded, which apps are protected and what still gets through. Part of our $3,500 fixed-price Entra ID security audit.

25+ yearsIT and cybersecurity experience
Certified expertsCISSP · C|CISO · Microsoft · Cisco
Southern CaliforniaLocal and on-site, based in Irvine
NationwideRemote audits and advisory
Why Conditional Access matters

Conditional Access is where your sign-in rules actually live

Conditional Access is the policy engine inside Microsoft Entra ID. Every time someone signs in, it looks at who the user is, which app they want, where they are, what device they use and how risky the sign-in looks, and then decides: allow, require MFA, require a compliant device, or block. If your company depends on Microsoft 365, these policies decide whether a stolen password becomes a breach.

The trouble is that policies drift. A vendor account is excluded "for now", a pilot policy stays in report-only mode, a new app is never added to the policy that protects the others, and nobody notices because nothing breaks. Our Conditional Access policy review reads every policy in your tenant, compares the design with Microsoft guidance and the CIS Microsoft 365 benchmark, and then checks your sign-in logs to see what really got through.

You get a clear list of gaps ranked by business risk, the exact policy changes to make, and a way to test each change safely before it affects your users.

Two IT professionals reviewing Conditional Access policies on a tablet in a server aisle
What we review

What the Conditional Access policy review checks

Each check has a result, the evidence behind it and the fix. These are the questions we answer about your policies.

01

MFA for every user, every app

Whether one policy requires MFA for all users on all cloud apps, or whether coverage depends on a patchwork of smaller policies.

02

Legacy authentication blocked

Older protocols such as IMAP, POP and SMTP AUTH cannot do MFA. We check that they are blocked and whether legacy sign-ins still succeed.

03

Administrators and admin portals

Whether admin roles and the Microsoft admin portals have their own, stronger policy, ideally requiring phishing-resistant MFA.

04

Sign-in risk and user risk

Whether risky sign-ins and users flagged as compromised trigger MFA, a password change or a block, where your licensing supports it.

05

Exclusions and break-glass accounts

Who is excluded from each policy and why. Emergency access accounts should be the only standing exclusions, and they should be monitored.

06

Report-only and disabled policies

Policies left in report-only or off since a pilot. We show what they would have blocked so you can decide whether to switch them on.

07

Device and location controls

Whether corporate apps require a compliant or hybrid-joined device, and how named locations and country blocks are used.

08

Session controls and registration

Sign-in frequency and persistent browser settings for privileged access, and whether registering MFA methods or joining devices is protected.

Sample findings

From the sample report: Conditional Access findings

These rows come from the sample audit of Veltrana Logistics, a fictional company. Your report lists every finding with the affected policies and users.

SeverityFinding (SAMPLE)What it means
HighNo policy responds to sign-in riskRisky sign-ins are detected but allowed to continue without extra checks.
HighNo policy responds to user riskA user flagged as compromised keeps working normally until someone notices.
MediumAdmin portals not targeted by a policySome admin roles must use MFA, but no policy protects the Microsoft admin portals for everyone who can reach them.
MediumRegistering security information not protectedAn attacker with a password alone could register their own MFA method.
MediumCompliant device not required for all usersThe device policy applies to one group, so most staff can sign in from any device.
LowPolicies with broad user exclusionsTwo enabled policies exclude more than three users or groups.
LowNo session controls for privileged accessNo policy sets sign-in frequency or turns off persistent browser sessions for admins.

Veltrana Logistics is a fictional company; all figures are illustrative. See the full sample report.

How it runs

Five steps, read-only from start to finish

1

Read-only access

Your Global Administrator approves our read-only audit app once, and we sign in with a Global Reader account. Nothing in your tenant is changed.

2

Policy inventory

We export every Conditional Access policy, named location, authentication strength and exclusion, and map which users and apps each policy really covers.

3

Gap analysis

We compare the policy set with Microsoft guidance and the CIS Microsoft 365 benchmark and list each gap with its business impact.

4

Proof from the logs

We check 30 days of sign-ins for successful single-factor, legacy-protocol and risky sign-ins that your policies should have stopped.

5

Safe rollout plan

Each fix comes with the order to apply it, a report-only test with the What If tool, and how to confirm it worked in the sign-in logs.

Microsoft Entra ID security audit
$3,500

fixed · any tenant size · read-only

What you receive from this review

Every Conditional Access finding in the Technical Security Report, with evidence and the exact fix
A Conditional Access inventory sheet in the Excel workbook
Conditional Access risks in the Risk Register, with owners and dates
The policy changes placed in your Next Steps and Security Roadmap
Readout with leadership and IT
Schedule a consultation

This review is part of the Entra ID audit. See what the price includes.

Related

More of the Microsoft Entra ID security audit

Ali Hassani, CISO and CISSP, standing in a professional data center
Who does the work

Every Conditional Access Policy Review is led by Ali Hassani, CISO

Certified CISO (C|CISO) and CISSP with 25+ years in IT, cybersecurity, compliance and infrastructure. Ali personally reviews every finding before it reaches your desk, and walks your leadership and IT team through the results.

He holds dozens of Microsoft and Cisco credentials (CCNP, CCNA, MCSE, MCITP, MCSA Security) and works on-site across Orange County, Los Angeles and Southern California, and remotely for organizations nationwide.

CISSPC|CISOCCNPCCNAMCSEMCITPMCSA Security
FAQ

Questions about this review

Do we need Microsoft Entra ID P1 or P2 for Conditional Access?
Conditional Access needs Microsoft Entra ID P1, which is included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium and E3. Risk-based policies need Entra ID P2. We review what your licenses allow and never require you to buy anything for the audit.
We use security defaults. Is this review still useful?
Yes. Security defaults give a basic baseline, but they cannot target specific apps, devices or locations and cannot be tuned. We explain what you have today and what a Conditional Access policy set would add.
Will the review change or disable any of our policies?
No. The review is read-only. We report what to change and how to test it, and your IT team, your MSP or IT Perfection makes the changes.
How do you test a policy before it is enforced?
We recommend report-only mode and the What If tool, then checking the sign-in logs for users the policy would have affected. Each recommendation in the report includes these validation steps.
Can we book only the Conditional Access review?
The Conditional Access review is part of the Microsoft Entra ID security audit, which is $3,500 fixed for any tenant size and also covers admins, apps, guests and 30 days of sign-in logs.
Consultant reviewing an Entra ID audit report with a client

Find the identity gaps before an attacker does.

A CISO-led, read-only Entra ID audit with 75 checks, 30 days of sign-in analysis and a 180-day roadmap, for one fixed price.